A comparison of salt mixes

Mixing IO, I have to use 3 cups for each 5 gallons to get a SG of 1.026.
Dave
 
If the salt has been sitting around for awhile additives can settle out. Before I open a new bucket I usually roll it so I can remix what might have settled out or went to the bottom. You notice I said "usually". That is the reason they say mix the whole bucket to get their numbers. Who really knows how long it may be sitting in a warehouse.
 
ares;402326 wrote: well I know its been said that reefsalt uses boron or something to produce their magnesium level... Im no chemist, so I cant understand it, but it would fit with the low mag level and elevated boron level.

in any event, they dont qualify if thats even reefsalt, as seachem makes a regular mix too.

I believe the boron is actually present in the form of a borate, utilized for buffering capacity. I'm no chemist either, though.

Seachem uses MgSO4- as their magnesium source, which has nothing to do with boron. Combining(rudimentally) magnesium with boron would result in an insoluble mineral.
 
Well my water has been mixing for 24hrs with a 300gph pump in a 5 gal bucket so we will see how it goes.
 
Results of my H2ocean tests.

Tested out at ph 8.3, calcium 450, DKH at 9.8 salinity was 1.024, phosphates 0, nitrates 0, ammonia 0
 
The last time I tested Seachem Reef Salt (not the Marine Salt)

Calcium 450 ppm
Alkalinity 8 dKH
Magnesium 1450 ppm

These were with Salifert Test kits.

I really only have to dose Buffer on a regular basis. Every once and a while Calcium.

I think this salt is the best bang for you dollar. D-D H2Ocean is a great salt mix that I special order once in a while for some customers, it is $20 more than Seachem and has roughly the same test results.

And yes certain elements can settle and throw off test results by either reading too low or too high. By mixing the largest amount possible will give a more accurate reading of the true levels.

Tim
 
i love io salt have always used it with almost no problems (crap now i did it im going to have problems lol )
 
I think everybody has their own opinions on salt. Like I've said previously, I prefer IO Reef Crystals. I used IO salt over 35 years ago and have had no salt problems with it. I've tried other salts with varying success. If you've been doing this for awhile and have a salt that does a good job for you I say "stick with it". If you do try a different salt don't just change salt. Slowly add new salt to whatever you normally use. That is, if you mix 5 gallons at a time start with 2 cups normal salt and 1/2 cup of new brand. Next time go with 1 1/2 cups normal brand and 1 cup new brand. Keep increasing by 1/2 cup til you get to all new brand. Like most things in this hobby it is always a good idea to take your time. IMO
I do find that Seachem takes at least 12-16 hours to mix thoroughly where IO salt mixes in 1-2 hours (5 gallon batches with a 300 gph pump) Needed to change some water and only had Seachem, no water made up, mixed up 5 gallons w/pump for 3 hours, clouded my water in seahorse tank for 2 days. My advice is like I tell my kids and grand kids, "Do As I Say NOT As I Do !!!" LOL
 
I usually get a bucket or 200gal box of reef crystals when I'm down to 1 bag or half bucket but didn't when I bought the Sachem (that's all I had at the time). I also Usually have a 5 gallon bucket aerating for at least 24 hrs. I'm just a di-hard IO fan I guess. It was the first salt I used about 35 years ago, I think there was one other salt mix at the time and have had consistent results all these years, so I didn't have much choice at that time. Nobody really new much about the salt water fish let alone corals back then. If you had something hat lives for over 3 months you were doing good, sad but true. Even though I'm pretty well set on IO reef crystals I'll try others just because that's the nameof the game. It is cool, with all that has been learned about the keeping of saltwater creatures thru the years, to have fish, critters and corals not only live for many years but to thrive and reproduce. Just like salt this hobby has come a long way, Much of the "oldshool" ways were not wrong just not enough (some stuff was stupid looking back at it now). I have found that using the knowledge of what I have learned thru the years plus applying a good bit of the new technology has been my formula for successful saltwater habitats. This holds true for the advancement in the formulations of salts.

I'm sorry I ran off on a tangent, you are right by saying that aerating the salt mix does help to mix it quicker. All I guess I meant to say is that IO salt mixes /dissolves much quicker, for me than Seachem. They're both good salts and I'll say it again, I think whatever works for each individual hobbyist is the best salt for them.
 
Back
Top