A vent about my own ignorance

PJs_Bucket_List

Member
Supporting
Messages
68
Reaction score
49
Location
Chatsworth
I've had numerous freshwater tanks all my adult life. Always wanted a saltwater reef tank, and I foolishly assumed it wasn't all that much different. So, in true "newbie" style, I skimmed a few articles and jumped into the saltwater hobby. Oh, boy! First, can we talk about buyer's remorse? See, I read the bit about tank size...too small, and it's hard to keep parameters stable. A big tank wasn't an option, both due to my available space and the expense, because you guessed it...I didn't read that helpful bit of advice about buying used. Or reef ready/drilled. So I ended up with a 45 gallon undrilled tank from PetSmart with a HOB filter. At least the stand was included 😂, but the LED lights were unusable, as saltwater would wreck them in no time. Ah well, I can still build the tank of my dreams, right? All the pretty fish, the coral...a beautiful little piece of the ocean in my living room. I was advised to research, research, research. No problem! I'm the academic, nerdy sort, so this was the easy part. Accepting the results of this research without losing my mind? Not so easy. Sticker shock for every single thing related to the hobby, patience is a must because nothing comes fast or easy (patience is not a virtue I possess), the "ugly phase" is inevitable, Murphy's Law reigns supreme, there are no saltwater stores or other reefers in my area, and even making water is a science project (what do you mean, I can't even use the water from my faucet?! And I have to cook it?!). In fact, at least once a week I'm playing "scientist", decked out in gloves and whatnot, testing, working in the tank, making water, etc. Realizing I wouldn't be getting the reef of my dreams anytime soon was disappointing, but I can accept that. Knowing that if I patiently work my way up, from the softies to LPS to SPS, I'll get there eventually. The pill I can't swallow, however, comes right back to my initial gripe of this post and my own impatient ignorance. Notice my screen name (it's pretty significant). This endeavor isn't just a hobby to me, and I messed up right out of the gate, with a tank that's too small for the fish I want. Tangs, reef safe butterflies and angelfish, a little school darting among the rocks...none of it fits in a 45 gallon tank. As luck would have it, a fellow ARC member is selling a 100 gallon tank for the very generous price of a $20 donation to our club. It's worth far more than that to me, the chance to build a dream and get it right this time, and truly be able to check it off my bucket list. I just have to figure out how to transport it the hour and a half distance, build a stand, and get it set up right. There's really no point to this post, just ranting, as the title says. Every reefer is different, or so I've heard. A lot of issues and setbacks in common, but no two journeys are the same. We all have our own gripes and failures, our own brags and celebrations, our own little anecdotes along the way to the perfect little piece of the ocean we keep in glass boxes. I guess this is part of mine. Maybe one day a new reefer will come along, feeling discouraged, and read it. Then see a picture of my (hopefully) beautiful reef tank, and not lose hope that they can do this. It just takes research, patience, and genuinely caring about the outcome and the living creatures in that glass box. Oh, and money 🤑...it takes a good amount of that, too 😂. Happy Sunday, fellow reefers! Stay safe and stay blessed.
 
Most of us start out in a similar fashion, learning as we go and I have been there with where you are in your saltwater journey. A sump allows more options for equipment, but the 45 Gallon you have could absolutely grow into a beautiful tank. Yes, the 45 is taller than ideal from a lighting perspective and realizing the limitations of the decisions made at the time of purchase can be tough especially if your dream fish don't fit within it now. I've been through a bunch of tanks. Why? I was either chasing perfection or branching off into new directions as new things about this hobby interested me. However, from experience, the tank will never be big enough, and when it is big enough, the cost to maintain it (both money and time) can be significantly more. Keep doing what you are doing, while you plan for the bigger tank, and do it better with what you know now vs. then. Do you have a build thread for the 45 gallon? I'm lousy at maintaining my own build threads, but I always enjoy being reminded of a) what I didn't know at the time (a lot!), b) how far the fish and corals have come when I look back.

I had no idea what I was doing here: https://atlantareefclub.org/threads/cooks-105-planet-aquariums-crystaline-reef.1170345/

My current tank: https://atlantareefclub.org/threads/cooks-180-gallon.1187451/

Lastly, a former reefer who showed me that beauty can be 20 gallons big:
 
Even season hobbyist has days they wanna break down. I probably lost 10-20k in livestock just last in this year alone with the move and remodeling. It’s about how to take it. Some get out. Other comes back with more back up plans.

Don’t let hiccups get you down. People that push through always come back better
 
The 100g is going to have its own challenges too since you just need so much more of everything - storage for top-off and water-change water, 3-4 (or more) lights instead of 1-2, and god help you if you need to buy a UV!
 
Enjoyed reading your rent/ inspiration :)

I also started off with 20Gallon non drilled saltwater tank (full of algae and heater failure killed only thing that was alive which was engineer goby within a day of purchasing off Facebook). That didn’t stop me. BUT I am still wanting to know who it was from this ARC group who exchanged my Brand new MRC sump (I bought off market place) with broken reef octopus skimmer when I was a newbie. Older hobbyist taking advantage of newer hobbyist was a thing in the past and I have to admit, someone try to pull that on me recently from ARC’s well known member. lol
 
Enjoyed reading your rent/ inspiration :)

I also started off with 20Gallon non drilled saltwater tank (full of algae and heater failure killed only thing that was alive which was engineer goby within a day of purchasing off Facebook). That didn’t stop me. BUT I am still wanting to know who it was from this ARC group who exchanged my Brand new MRC sump (I bought off market place) with broken reef octopus skimmer when I was a newbie. Older hobbyist taking advantage of newer hobbyist was a thing in the past and I have to admit, someone try to pull that on me recently from ARC’s well known member. lol
Wow, that's not right. I've somehow obtained a free aiptasia anemone. If you know it's in your tank, either don't sell frags from the tank, or at least warn a buyer it's a possibility, ya know? I seem to be running through the list of potential issues, with algae and the like, at least. Gha, brown hair algae, diatoms (until a dose of pods and my diamond goby was introduced), cyano. While treating a frag with gha today, a closer look revealed what appears to be bryopsis. I need better filtration, for sure. Maybe reduce my lighting period and keep on scrubbing and siphoning. Except for the bryopsis. I read that scrubbing breaks it up and makes the problem worse. Thankfully I haven't had any major losses. So I keep chugging along, telling myself I'm going to get there eventually, and all of the frustration, headaches, heartaches, muscle aches, and protesting wallet will be worth it 😉.
 
You are winning my friend :). We all dealt with most all the things you’ve mentioned and in some cases we also live with em because it’s impossible to get rid of them. It’s fine balance which we come to enjoy.

I’ve been out of country for last two weeks and heading back tommorow and expect all things to be okay. Wife just had to feed to tank. Nothing else. Fingers cross. Heard so many awful stories in the past and told my wife I would never blame her for anything happens to my tank. Happy marriage and happy tanks. Hahaha
 
My husband initially thought I was crazy when I started this tank, because it's so much more complicated and expensive than the freshwater tanks we have. But then I took him to some LFSs, and started adding life to the tank. Now he gets it, and he loves it almost as much as I do!
 
Back
Top