Depends on your sump really. Those panes at lowes or HD are "ok" on something like a 30g sump. Granted yes you have a higher chance of them breaking because they are so thin. If your sump is larger, I'd definitely go thicker so it can withstand the pressure of more water on them. As Kelley said, 1/4" is nice. You may also be able to get some acrylic cut. I have a 55g sump and have 1/4" acrylic sheets...use a little more silicone and make sure it cures for a solid day and you should be good.