Experimenting with natural removal of aptasia using mechanical means

dakota9

Active Member
Market
Messages
3,171
Reaction score
8
I read a post where Jenn's Scott dipped live rock into straight vinegar to remove aptasia. To be honest, I had thought of the same approach, but like Jenn, was concerned with the amount of beneficial bacteria I'd loose with this method. Also, I have grown a nice crop of very small serpent stars for the first time in reefing, and would like to keep them.

Keep in mind I currently have the worse outbreak of aptasia I've ever seen, due to a cracked tank issue last summer, and less than optimum makeshift conditions my rock endured until the new tank was ready. As a result of the atasia, the rocks look almost fuzzy from 10 feet away.

This may not be every one's answer, but so far, it's working for me.

This is the method I'm testing, and will post more results as they play out:
Using a very large frag plug, I cover an area of aptasia infestation. The aptasia move onto the plug in order to get to the light. After all the aptasia in that area attach to the frag plug, I remove the plug and give it a vinegar soak, rinse it in a container of tank water and replace it in the tank, over another infested area to begin the process again.

I'd have taken pictures of this, as you can now see two rough circular areas where no aptasia exsist, but to be honest, I'm just too embarrassed of my tank to take pictures right now.

I do not presume this will take care of all of them, but it's certainly making a huge dent in the population, after only a few days. If I get rid of the overgrowth, maybe the Peppermint Shrimp will have more interest in eating the younger ones that will undoubtedly pop up in the treated areas.

I'll keep you posted....
 
I would get a large tupperware or borrow a tank and remove all fish to eliminate feedings. Maybe even pay an lfs to house them for you.
Then get a bulk buy of peppermint shrimp and let them have at it for a month or two. Granted you will have a boring tank but the rewards will be no aiptasia.
I really want to know how the vinegar bath works though.
If you are only worried about your mini serpent population I can send you a bag full. They wind up filling up the skimmer cups in mine and my buddie's tanks afterall
 
Joe's Juice would be impractical as I'd need to use so much, It would screw with my ph.

I have two pepperments, they seem to be happy living out their lives in my overflow eating nothing at all from what I can tell, as that is where I've find them every morning after moving them back to the tank.

I've never found star fish in any of the cups of the small skimmers I've used, but would like to have more star fish if you were serious.
 
See if anyone has any berghias you can buy/borrow. Sounds like they are the aiptasia lawn mowers of the hobby.
 
The pepps in the overflow probably live off of extra foood and anything they can scrape off of the walls. I'll let you know when I head up next and get with you on the mini stars. Also wrasses and larger stars love to eat them.
 
Chymos45;407793 wrote: See if anyone has any berghias you can buy/borrow. Sounds like they are the aiptasia lawn mowers of the hobby.



I WOULD LUUUVVV a Berghia, but budget won't allow it right now...... Hoping I can pick one up in a month or two after the ones purchased in the recent group buy decimate the populations of aptasia in their current tank...
 
^^ good plan. Maybe some will reproduce (or probably have already) and you can get one for a steal from a fellow reefer that is feeling generous or takes pity on you...:D
 
Dakota9;407842 wrote: I WOULD LUUUVVV a Berghia, but budget won't allow it right now...... Hoping I can pick one up in a month or two after the ones purchased in the recent group buy decimate the populations of aptasia in their current tank...

I'm in that same boat....a broke joke and want to buy two or three of the little buggers. I don't have a huge infestation as of yet.....crossing fingers that it will stay that way until I have the money and someone has a couple to unload. I'll be all over it!

And....on a side note, glad to see you working with your tank for its betterment. Does this mean that you are feeling a bit better in regards to your reefing?
 
Yes, cleaning it did help, plus Simon was gererous enough to give me some huge pieces of bleached live rock that I used to dress up the aquascaping, and I met Big D (the "D" stands for Dave........... I guess, lol j/k) and he helped me out big time with an LPS I'd been wanting...... I also added additional filteration, put still need to add my UV

Thanks for asking
 
See....you just needed a small breath of fresh air sent your reefs way. GREAT! Was afraid we were gonna have to talk you down off of the 18th story ledge :D
 
ga_daisy;407868 wrote: Was afraid we were gonna have to talk you down off of the 18th story ledge :D




.......or atleast beg me to throw down the assault rifle.... LOL
 
ares;407876 wrote: Ive heard of people injecting boiling water into them using a syringe? I dont know the effectiveness of this... but perhaps a cheap(cost of a syringe) option to try out, if you do, let us know if it works.
I've talked with older reefers on rc and that is all they have ever used.
 
I'm going to continue with the method I'm currently using, as I'm removing them faster than they can multiply at the moment. When I thin the herd alil more, that won't be the case with the current method, and might consider that an option if a Berghia Nudi isn't fourth coming.......
 
Back
Top