I have two inkbirds, one on each tank. They have been super reliable. My only complaint is the 1 degree temperature differential, meaning at best, the heater outlet will turn on when the temperature is one degree less your target temp and the cooling when it is one degree above your target temp. I wish it could do half a degree.
Some good news though!!! I heard BRS say they are working with InkBird to release a new version in the near future with a temperature differential less than one degree.
I haven't heard of the second one you listed, but if you go with it, I would attempt to see if this probe would work with it, rather than the metal one you listed. If not, you can put silicone on the metal part of the probe. If you get that second one, please let me know; it would be cool to monitor the temperature remotely.
Amazon.com: Inkbird Detachable Aquarium Probe for Heating and Cooling Temperature Controller for ITC-308 ITC-306T and ITC-308S Freshwater Saltwater Aquarium : Pet Supplies
www.amazon.com
By the way, there is an older version of the InkBird that doesn't have the removable temperature probe; it comes with an attached metal one instead, so if you decide to get an InkBird, just make sure you get the one with the plastic probe (like the one
@ZapataInc listed), which will be better in saltwater.