tnks jenn, I dont know what happend there i felt like with the big water change and new salt, ro water it would have to be better than the tank he was in, i neglected it over the past couple of months b/c i knew the transfer was coming, i was out of salt too, I will do the testing tonite but i really feel like all params will be acceptable. I got the salinity the same in both and the temp within a couple of degrees. but who knows, I was really excited to get him out of that little tank into the larger at least he got to stretch his legs for a few mins, thnks everyone for the help and advice but i feel like something was wrong with him before.