It's always safer to acclimate... Ive burnt corals just by replacing current MH bulbs. I personally usually do ON for a couple hours and increase time over the period or a week or two. Plus, I'm just lazy and dont like keeping screen on top of my tank and paying for electricity that Im just blocking anyway.
I think when I origionally moved from PC to MH I did:
Day 1: 3Hrs MH
Day 2: 3Hrs MH
Day 3: 4Hrs MH
Day 4: 4Hrs MH
Day 5: 5Hrs MH
Day 6: 5Hrs MH
Day 7: 5Hrs MH
Day 8: 6Hrs MH
Day 9: 7Hrs MH
Day 10: 8Hrs MH
Day 11: 8Hrs MH
Day 12: 8Hrs MH
Day 13: 8Hrs MH
Day 14: 9Hrs MH
Just make sure you monitor the reaction to your corals on a daily basis. If you see any signs of bleaching, RTN, No polyp extension, etc. then hold off on increasing time or lower the corals in the tank (or both). Pay attention to the temperature of the tank as well... Every system, biotope and coral can react differently. You just never know...
Good luck!