Need ID .. Good or Bad Star?

[hellfire]

alt="" />

Now I have TONS of Asterina starfish. They are white with a little bit of grey in the center. This guy is 10x bigger, and brown. He's the only one I've found in there.

Leave or take him out?

Tyler

 

[james s_]

Leave

 

[hellfire]

Thats what I figured as well. Just wanted a second opinion. Back in he goes.

Tyler

 

[jennm]

Call him Fred

 

[lilrobb]

Hellfire;359414 wrote: They are white with a little bit of grey in the center.

I actually spotted those munching on my zoas - the brown ones never did.

 

[hellfire]

Huh.. I have never really had a problem with them, but I'll make sure to keep an eye on them. There are so many, I don't think I could ever get them all out.

Tyler

 

[mvm]

Usually the ones with 6 legs are bad. I'd toss it and get a harlequin shrimp

 

[radha]

No!! The grey ones are bad, they munch zoas. I've witnessed this happen. Orange/brown are fine. I would say that goes back in the tank, it's pretty orange looking to me.