- Messages
- 201
- Reaction score
- 0
I have read several books or articles by both and think they are both great contributors to our hobby. With that said...I am a little confused over a topic they totally disagree on.
Scott Michael states that the Acanthurus nigricans (Whitecheek or Gold Rimmed) is a much hardier selection than Acanthurus japonicus (Powder Brown Tang). Bob Fenner says the exact opposite. Both seem to have strong feelings on the subject.
Any experiences between the two? Experience with either would be great as well. I guess that is what makes this hobby so interesting. Two respected authors with two total opposite opinions on the same species of fish.
Your opinions, observations and experiences are appreciated.
Scott Michael states that the Acanthurus nigricans (Whitecheek or Gold Rimmed) is a much hardier selection than Acanthurus japonicus (Powder Brown Tang). Bob Fenner says the exact opposite. Both seem to have strong feelings on the subject.
Any experiences between the two? Experience with either would be great as well. I guess that is what makes this hobby so interesting. Two respected authors with two total opposite opinions on the same species of fish.
Your opinions, observations and experiences are appreciated.