what are some good test kits?

jmt

New Member
Messages
23
Reaction score
0
Hello all, I was in the market for some test kits and was looking to test calcium, magnesium, alk, and nitrates. I have read on line that the elos kits are top notch but on the expensive side. Are they worth the money? I am also very new to testing, so I am also looking for something relatively simple.

Is there any suggestions you can provide?

Thanks in advance!
 
Elos and Salifert rank at the top. As with many things, you get what you pay for.
 
I agree, you get what you pay for, but by the same token, if you keep fairly hearty species, and are on the beginner to intermediate side of the hobby, API tests are "close enough"......

In other words it really matters little if your nitrites are 8.0 with API and 6.2 with Elos. The average person just needs to know if they have nitrites.

I typically opt for inexpensive test kits, and if I suspect that I'm getting consecutive false readings using them, I confirm it at a LFS.

After a tank is set up a while, and regular maintenance is done, testing isn't all that important.

Edit: I agree, you get what you pay for, but by the same token, if you keep fairly hearty species, and are on the beginner to intermediate side of the hobby, API tests are "close enough"......

In other words it really matters little if your nitrites are 8.0 with API and 6.2 with Elos. The average person just needs to know if they have nitrites.

I typically opt for inexpensive test kits, and if I suspect that I'm getting consecutive false readings using them, I confirm it at a LFS.

After a tank is set up a while, and regular maintenance is done, testing isn't all that important.
 
Inexpensive test kits are better than no test kits, but if there is one kit that is more accurate, then I would opt for it over another. Salifert is more expensive than API, for example, but most any test kit will last for a long period of time, so the higher cost is not as big a deal if you look at using it over a year+ or however long the reagents last.

I don't quite agree that regular testing is not all that important, as testing helps identify trends happening in your tank, but it is a choice each reefer makes, and once your tank is established, may not be required weekly, but I still test my tanks for KH, Magnesium, and Calcium levels every 2-3 weeks.

Whatever test kit you buy, though, hopefully, if it is off by X units, then it will be consistently off by X units so you can still track trends in the tank, even if the reading is not spot on.

I personally like Elos, mainly because of their attention to the accuracy of liquid reagent volume delivery through NIST certification of reagant containers, their use of glass test vials that don't scratch or cloud and retain colors from previous tests that can happen with plastic vials, their handling requirements their Sellers must agree to (temperature controlled storage), and their use of low toxicity reagents vs other test kits (Salifert).
 
I will just add that the Salifert kit I have to CA reads low I discovered the other day. I also have a Seachem CA test kit and they were reading about 70 points apart.

The one thing that Seachem includes with their kits is a solution that is test water that is rated to a certain specific reading. In this case calcium is rated at 470. Salifert read the sample at 400. :doh:

I do agree with using API for the basics as they are cheap. For ammonia, nitrate and nitrite, you really only need to know that you have a problem. If you do and need accurate testing, then you can always take it into a good LFS.
 
stacy22;701860 wrote: Elos and Salifert rank at the top. As with many things, you get what you pay for.


Elos 1
Salifert 2

(DD Merck or Hach for phates)
 
Back
Top