Personally, I'm a little gunshy of buying a seahorse from a LFS unless they got it directly from a dedicated breeding facility. There's too much chance of them being wild caught if they cant guarantee that they came directly to that lfs from a reputable breeder, and not through a middleman. I would recommend ordering from one of the dedicated facilities that breed them on site, have the pathogen-free guarantee.. already trained them to eat frozen foods, etc...
I will be ordering a new pair shortly, and am doing my research right now on where I want to get them since my fav. place is out of stock (and probably out of business, lol). I'll let ya know what I find in the next day or two.
(and no offense to the lfs's that sponsor the club... If you can guarantee me the above conditions, then I'd be happy to talk to yall about purchasing them, but so far unless I special order them, I havent found anyone that can, so i've gotten mine from the facilities such as ocean rider and draco marine so far... the one horse I took a chance on from a lfs died very quickly).