4.4g Camel Shrimp Tank

ripped tide

Active Member
Market
Messages
2,920
Reaction score
0
After hearing a few rumors that camel shrimp will clean coral of any parasites, I decided that I am going to test this hypothesis out.

I have a 4.4g acrylic tank that I had built for my wife back in December, but she lost interest after a few months and I shut it down. I plan on having a few pounds of sand and a pound or two of rock (just enough for the shrimp to cling to). I'll use a small hang on filter that will hold polyester filter floss and a small amount of carbon to remove some organics. I won't use a skimmer, and normally wouldn't advocate this, but the size of the tank is going to cause limitations on what skimmer would work. This tank will not be plumbed into my main tank, but I will use water from the main tank when doing water changes. I plan on stocking the tank with 6-8 camel shrimp.

Once the tank is set up and the shrimp have been introduced, I'll be ready to test. If anyone has any infested corals that they would like to put through trial and tribulation let me know!

I'll be using this as a dip for any new corals coming into my tank. I have had mixed results from using reef dip, coral rx, and melafix marine as a dip and decided it might be fun to try a more natural route. The Europeans have been using this method for a while. They recommend keeping the shrimp hungry and allowing the coral to dip anywhere from 10-30mins depending on amount of shrimp and size of coral. Most importantly, I will sit there and watch the shrimp and make sure they don't pull off polyps.

Comments? Opinions? Questions?
 
I'll keep everything posted. My shrimp should be in on Wednesday

Edit: I may try to take a video of the first few dips, I'll probably give them a week to settle in.
 
:) im pretty sure it will work...did you read anything else about it? ill look back and see if i can find the website i found it on.
 
nholderried65;700581 wrote: :) im pretty sure it will work...did you read anything else about it? ill look back and see if i can find the website i found it on.

I have only read testimonials about it. I haven't searched too deep, but I think it would be a neat project even if it is a fail. I have all the equipment minus the sand and spare rock, so I'll only have to invest the cost of shrimp plus $50(for sand and rock) or so. Thats pretty cheap for a SW setup so even if i have to shut it down in three months, I'll at least have experience to share. And if it works, then I will have "found" a cheap and effective remedy for coral parasites and will share about my positive experiences.
 
nholderried65;700627 wrote: bet it works on the bugs but ull still have eggs

then they hatch and theyre dead :)


you could charge to have it setup as a natural quarantine tank...i know peeps like myself without a proper hospital tank wouldnt mind the shrimp snacking on any unwanted pests on my new coral...of coarse i wont have to pay since i gave you this great idea right? :)
 
ya, but it takes time for them to hatch and the shrimp may start to eat the coral. i read about this method about a year ago, but i never had a prob with red bugs so i never got a chance to try it.

Hammcd;701025 wrote: then they hatch and theyre dead :)


you could charge to have it setup as a natural quarantine tank...i know peeps like myself without a proper hospital tank wouldnt mind the shrimp snacking on any unwanted pests on my new coral...of coarse i wont have to pay since i gave you this great idea right? :)
 
Hammcd;701025 wrote: then they hatch and theyre dead :)


you could charge to have it setup as a natural quarantine tank...i know peeps like myself without a proper hospital tank wouldnt mind the shrimp snacking on any unwanted pests on my new coral...of coarse i wont have to pay since i gave you this great idea right? :)

That's pretty much what I intend to do. I won't charge ANYONE to use it, all I'll ask in return is that you post your experiance watching the shrimp.

I have 6 camel shrimp that should arrive tomorrow. I'm excited!!!
 
I would also use a bit of Purigen in the HOB filter.

For my 6 gallon fluval, I emtied a bad of old purigen(I had let it completely dry out between bleaching which you're not supposed to do...) and poured a little bit of new purigen in the old bag and sewn it up.

One of those bags treats like 100 gallons, so I just used a tblsp in the bag and it fits great in the filter....

just MHO
 
http://glassbox-design.com/2009/got-aes-acropora-eating-snails-unwelcome-in-sps-reefs/">http://glassbox-design.com/2009/got-aes-acropora-eating-snails-unwelcome-in-sps-reefs/</a>

here the link to that pest snail i was telling you about last week end
 
nholderried65;701171 wrote: http://glassbox-design.com/2009/got-aes-acropora-eating-snails-unwelcome-in-sps-reefs/">http://glassbox-design.com/2009/got-aes-acropora-eating-snails-unwelcome-in-sps-reefs/</a>

here the link to that pest snail i was telling you about last week end[/QUOTE]

Hmm... you don't think that's what was causing those weird grooves you were finding, do you?

Dakota, I may throw a little purigen in there. The main reason I run carbon, is because I like how clear it makes the water look. Purigen never really clarifies things for me.
 
The only issue I see in this is with camel shrimp, comes coral getting eaten. How would u know they would go for the bugs and not your coral. Those that don't think camel shrimp can cause havoc ... I Accidently added 3 into a solona within the weekend that I was away, the coral got raped...
 
just got to watch thanh, we know te shrip will rape the coral but they should get the bug first...i read about this awhile back and if i remember right ripped gave me that your a duma$$ look the first time i told him about it
 
nholderried65;701535 wrote: just got to watch thanh, we know te shrip will rape the coral but they should get the bug first...i read about this awhile back and if i remember right ripped gave me that your a duma$$ look the first time i told him about it

Lol, I may have, hopefully only in a friendly way :D, BUT, I have enough faith in your research that I am going to test it out. Got the shrimp acclimated this evening... no pics yet, its pretty boring anyways: shrimp and sand. The neat thing is all the weird little critters that popped out of the bag of live sand. With out introducing ANY live rock or established water, I have seen about a dozen mysis shrimp zipping around the tank and a bunch of pods. Pretty impressive considering that bag had to have been sealed for 6 months or so. I wonder if there were just dormant eggs that hatched once appropriate conditions came about, or if they have actually been SURVIVING in there...

I am not intending on feeding these guys much, so i am sure that they will eat most of these hitch-hikers. I'm going to give them a week to settle, and then begin the testing. A friend is going to give me either a coral or a rock that has flat worms on it to see how they respond to those.
 
Ripped Tide;701539 wrote: Lol, I may have, hopefully only in a friendly way :D, BUT, I have enough faith in your research that I am going to test it out. Got the shrimp acclimated this evening... no pics yet, its pretty boring anyways: shrimp and sand. The neat thing is all the weird little critters that popped out of the bag of live sand. With out introducing ANY live rock or established water, I have seen about a dozen mysis shrimp zipping around the tank and a bunch of pods. Pretty impressive considering that bag had to have been sealed for 6 months or so. I wonder if there were just dormant eggs that hatched once appropriate conditions came about, or if they have actually been SURVIVING in there...

I am not intending on feeding these guys much, so i am sure that they will eat most of these hitch-hikers. I'm going to give them a week to settle, and then begin the testing. A friend is going to give me either a coral or a rock that has flat worms on it to see how they respond to those.

ya it was lol i dont blame you i think ive told you some of the most off the wall ways to do things.
 
Back
Top