Feedback on rock structure

[hzheng33]

No feelings will be hurt. Give it to me raw: so you like aquascape #1 or #2. Because #2 is new, so it looks out of place but eventually the rocks will blend in.

 

[hzheng33]

#2

 

[hzheng33]

Close up of the Tonga branches on the right

 

[york1]

I like #2 The center part seems a bit small. Maybe it could use some more height ? Looks good tho

 

[dball711]

This is just my opinion but I like structure number one because I love the open spaces and I think it’ll look great with a bunch of Corals growing off of the structure rather than a bunch of Corals growing off the branch structure in number two. The one thing I don’t like about all of it is that it’s not in my home…really You did a great job of both they both look great.

 

[york1]

This is just my opinion but I like structure number one because I love the open spaces and I think it’ll look great with a bunch of Corals growing off of the structure rather than a bunch of Corals growing off the branch structure in number two. The one thing I don’t like about all of it is that it’s not in my home…really You did a great job of both they both look great.

Dammit I agree but i still think the centerpiece needs something more.

 

[AquariumSchmo]

I feel like #2 has a little too much tonga for a single structure. Maybe just do a little on each. I would make the center structure a little taller too.

 

[jcook54]

It's almost like #1 needed just a bit more rock on the side against the returns. That would have made it so both sides looked fairly equal with a smaller center. Still have lots of open space, which is good, but it would have been more balanced. In #1 the side against the return used to be less substantial that it's counterpart on the other end of the tank and in #2 it's gotten quite a bit more substantial than it.

Of course both do look good but if I had to absolutely choose one, I'd go with #2.

 

[hzheng33]

thank you all for the feedback.

initially, the idea is to have 1 large area on the right side and 1 large area on the left side with a small center piece in the middle. And then by chance i came across some tonga rocks that you can't even buy nowadays. so i jumped on the opportunity and decided to incorporate it into my tank. the tonga structure is multiple rocks cemented or pegged together. i can easily take out a few pieces to make it less bulky as @AquariumSchmo has stated.

decisions decisions.

 

[CJD18]

I think you need more cow bell!!

 

[snowmansnow]

I’m personally not a fan of that Tonga ..


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[snowmansnow]

How big is that tank? ?? Makes those rocks look like rubble ha


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Tjb61885]

I think it looks good