LFS going extinct?

iifeainteasy;1045849 wrote: this hobby is too complicated for beginners IMO. too many variables with fish and coral to scare away or even waste money of new aquarium hobbyist. Also, every fish store i went to i explained to them my setup was only 1 week, 2 weeks, 3 weeks, old... but everyone still sold me fish and coral as if they didnt care. Not saying its their fault or they were trying to sabotage my tank. i think they cared for the sale more than the longevity of a customer in the hobby. Same with equipment. LFS wanted me to buy a LED light from them at $$$. when a sales rep WHISPERED that i can go on ebay and get chinese LEDs for cheap. thats the type of info i need. to keep me in this hobby. this hobby just takes alot of research and money to be successful. and for newcomers on a budget. most cant afford LFS so we use the internet and save 20-40%. i never bought livestock due to shipping cost. But my lighting and skimmer were from ebay. LFS should fear chain stores like petco more. their prices on fish are quite cheap. $20/$40 on clowns while LFS sells them for $30/$100. LFS keep a larger variety of fish and coral. but most arent for beginners. so i recommend petco for livestock and coral because its just cheaper basically. i love my LFS and go to 3 different ones often. another issue i had was with "ich" no one informed of a QT tank when i first got into the hobby. no one informed me of the long cycle period with no fish or coral. so first week i bought fish and coral. and had to start over my whole setup and do things correctly. now after 2342343 hours of youtube videos and reading forums. i feel i know the BASICS of SW keeping.

Sounds like you need to do some more research on the hobby and the type of tank you are trying to run. ARC is a great place to ask questions from people that have tons of experience keeping reef and fish only tanks. This hobby isnt cheap by any stretch but you can make it much more palatable if you do your research prior to your purchases. You get what you pay for at petco. I personally haven't seen many Petco stores that dont have sick fish. You may save a few bucks but that really doesnt matter if your fish and corals dont survive. One piece of advice I will give you that really helped me out was - Take your time, nothing in this hobby happens fast. The more research you do the better.
 
Most Sponsors get their Livestock from the exact same Wholesalers as petco..

No matter what a Store calls QT you do your OWN QT or you pay for it later.

Everyone likes to save a few bucks But as mentioned before IF you need it now LFS are great for those items.
 
Nickh06;1045852 wrote: Sounds like you need to do some more research on the hobby and the type of tank you are trying to run. ARC is a great place to ask questions from people that have tons of experience keeping reef and fish only tanks. This hobby isnt cheap by any stretch but you can make it much more palatable if you do your research prior to your purchases. You get what you pay for at petco. I personally haven't seen many Petco stores that dont have sick fish. You may save a few bucks but that really doesnt matter if your fish and corals dont survive. One piece of advice I will give you that really helped me out was - Take your time, nothing in this hobby happens fast. The more research you do the better.

I haven't seen any LFS who's tanks don't have sick fish either. this is part of the hobby. and my best surviving coral at this point is my 1 petco coral which would of been three times the price for its size at the LFS. and petco gives a 2 week warranty. so 2 weeks to see if your fish is healthy or not.
 
UmbrellaCorp;675174 wrote: i bough the majority of my stuff from my LFS. Even though i could have ordered the supplies online for a lot cheaper. I still buy minor things from them (when they have it in stock,) and i buy my livestock from them. The only thing i *never* buy online is livestock. I hate the idea of them being shipped in a box for 24+ hours to get to my house.. even though their prices are better on the livestock you still have to pay a ton for their next day shipping prices as well.

they get shipped in boxes when they go to the LFS . you're possibly saving the fish some stress by having it come straight to your house and into your QT.
 
iifeainteasy;1045858 wrote: I haven't seen any LFS who's tanks don't have sick fish either. this is part of the hobby. and my best surviving coral at this point is my 1 petco coral which would of been three times the price for its size at the LFS. and petco gives a 2 week warranty. so 2 weeks to see if your fish is healthy or not.

You might want to double check that warranty, the 2 weeks only applies to freshwater not saltwater.
 
iifeainteasy;1045858 wrote: I haven't seen any LFS who's tanks don't have sick fish either. this is part of the hobby. and my best surviving coral at this point is my 1 petco coral which would of been three times the price for its size at the LFS. and petco gives a 2 week warranty. so 2 weeks to see if your fish is healthy or not.


Sounds to me like you may be shopping at the wrong stores then. The two sponsor stores I have closest to me are excellent about ensuring their inventory is healthy when it leaves the store. Will one get past them on occasion? Sure. But the way I look at it, I would rather ride in a car with a driver who takes all safety precautions to minimize the chance of getting in a wreck than to ride with someone who willingly runs red lights, cuts people off and drives erratically. Yes both can still get in a wreck but one is much more likely to in my opinion.
 
This old thread just keeps coming back :)

To lifeainteasy - I'll disclose here that I owned a local shop for 11 1/2 years, packed it in coming up on 2 years ago. For me, it was time to move on to something else. I still do some off-site work for another shop. So that's where I 'come from' as it pertains to this thread.

iifeainteasy;1045849 wrote: this hobby is too complicated for beginners IMO. too many variables with fish and coral to scare away or even waste money of new aquarium hobbyist.

It is a complicated hobby. However there are unlimited resources available, most of them are free. The Internet has more information (both good and bad) nowadays, than the small collection of books and magazines that us old farts had access to, back in the day. There's no excuse for not being informed. Impulsiveness is not a reason to excuse a poor choice.


Also, every fish store i went to i explained to them my setup was only 1 week, 2 weeks, 3 weeks, old... but everyone still sold me fish and coral as if they didnt care.Not saying its their fault or they were trying to sabotage my tank. i think they cared for the sale more than the longevity of a customer in the hobby.
I love this one. So many folks blame the store. My comments below aren't necessarily directed at you, personally, but at people and human nature in general. Many here will attest that I unsold them out of a lot of things over the years, but that was just how I worked, and in MY shop, I got to decide. Still, I can't tell you how many times somebody would ignore the advice, and go buy it elsewhere (and then call me to fix the problem that resulted.)

Stores exist to sell things. That's how they pay their bills, their staff. And if one doesn't buy it from there, and they are heck-bent on buying it, they will go buy it someplace else, so why not close the sale?

I've never EVER seen a consumer forced to buy a luxury item. If one bought it, they wanted it, period. If they felt pressured, they had the option of leaving the business.

When it turns out to be a bad choice, it's much easier to blame the salesman, than to take ownership of a bad choice.


Same with equipment. LFS wanted me to buy a LED light from them at $$$. when a sales rep WHISPERED that i can go on ebay and get chinese LEDs for cheap.
That would be grounds for dismissal just about anywhere. They whispered so they wouldn't get caught and disciplined or fired. That employee is undermining his employer, and he's literally taking money out of his own pocket. If he continues to drive business away from the store, how will his wages be covered? Do YOU work for free? Or how would you feel if you were told that your work was not of as much value?

There's an old saying, "The bitterness of poor quality lasts long after the sweet price is forgotten." Not all equipment is created equal. Lots of people have ended up putting good money after bad, by having to replace substandard equipment that they thought was a 'good deal'.

And when one spends $$$ as you put it, at a brick and mortar store, where you got to see and touch and test the product, get information and advise on the product, after-sales support if there is a problem with the product, the difference in cost between an identical item bought at a brick and mortar, versus some anonymous e-vendor, is the VALUE ADDED in all of that personal service.



thats the type of info i need. to keep me in this hobby. this hobby just takes alot of research and money to be successful. and for newcomers on a budget. most cant afford LFS so we use the internet and save 20-40%.
So you think it's OK to use the LFS for information and then go buy stuff elsewhere. There is a new term called 'showrooming'. Let's make the salespeople work, then leave emptyhanded and go buy it online.

And people wonder why stores are in trouble. Not just aquarium shops, it's happening all across the retail spectrum.

If you want to buy online, go for it. Please just do your research online and don't waste the valuable time of people employed to serve paying customers. That will free up more time for the clerk to serve the customer who actually intends to make a purchase in the store. Then everybody wins.


i never bought livestock due to shipping cost. But my lighting and skimmer were from ebay. LFS should fear chain stores like petco more. their prices on fish are quite cheap. $20/$40 on clowns while LFS sells them for $30/$100.
Good luck getting warranty service if those eBay purchases fail ;)

As for LFS versus Petco... you're comparing guns and butter. But hey, knock yourself out. Hope you spent a few bucks on a quarantine system because if you didn't, Petco will bite you in the rear. Any fish from any source should be quarantined, but in most instances you're more likely to get a sick fish from a big box store whose mission is to turn and burn, than a local shop that takes pride in its offerings.


LFS keep a larger variety of fish and coral. but most arent for beginners. so i recommend petco for livestock and coral because its just cheaper basically.
Really? That's odd. My experience as a retailer was that the easy beginner stuff and inexpensive stuff sold like hotcakes all day long, and the expensive collector stuff got lots of oohs and ahhs but didn't sell nearly as well. Then again, that was my niche for the most part.

Again ... cheaper does not necessarily equal 'better'.

i love my LFS and go to 3 different ones often. another issue i had was with "ich" no one informed of a QT tank when i first got into the hobby. no one informed me of the long cycle period with no fish or coral. so first week i bought fish and coral. and had to start over my whole setup and do things correctly. now after 2342343 hours of youtube videos and reading forums. i feel i know the BASICS of SW keeping.
So whose fault is this again? Let me get this straight... you are expecting the LFS to hold your hand and educate you on every aspect of the hobby, and sell to you at Internet prices. Internet prices don't usually come with hours of service and education.

Would it not have been better for you, your wallet and your livestock, to watch the 2342343 hours of videos and research BEFORE you began?

I know... it's just easier to blame the people who sell the stuff, than to take responsibility for one's own ill-informed choices.
 
I was blaming the hobby itself. there's no set guideline to a successful tank. I find this hobby to be more trial and error more than anything. and I don't showroom because I make purchases. and for someone to say don't go to one place because you can find a better bargain isn't American. I will pay for what I feel I get the best value for my buck. my concerns are with the hobby. not so much the LFS.
 
I recommend you pick up a copy of The Conscientious Marine Aquarist by Robert Fenner. That's a great "set guideline" to a successful tank. Start there with the basics, and then you can play with all the other tweaks and such.

While there are many ways to do many things, there ARE indeed some absolutes, and it behooves every hobbyist to get a firm understanding of those before beginning. Nitrogen cycle - it's science, not speculation or theory. If you don't have that figured out, everything else is moot.

New innovations ARE trial and error and it was trial and error that advanced this hobby to the level it is now, but there is no reason for a new hobbyist to have to go through the same trials and errors that hobbyists did 30 years ago, unless they opt not to educate themselves.

Your concerns *will* be for the LFS the day your pump goes out and you need a replacement NOW. Unless you buy backups for everything and have them on hand, there will be a day when you have some kind of emergency and you'll hope there's still an actual store to help you out.

:)
 
I'll agree with Jenn on the book recommendation-- it was our first expense in the hobby. We did research for about six weeks BEFORE we bought our display tank from someone on this forum. Like any hobby, book knowledge will only carry you so far but it's a good place to start.

None of the experts in this field started out that way--at one point, they were all beginners. They've all had their victories and defeats. We've been very slow about some things-- the tank was up and running about nine months before we bought our first frags--and we bought cheap ones to learn if we could keep them alive! We are expanding little by little, and I would say we are reasonably good at fish husbandry. We are also having good luck with some of the softer corals and zoas. It might seem our patience has been remarkable, but I think it probably has more to do with the fact that our busy lives haven't allowed us to move as quickly as we might have wanted.

As for the LFS business model, it's possible Atlanta has more stores than it can fully support right now--I don't really know. I cannot imagine ever wishing to buy fish online; even with coral I like seeing what I'm buying. The level of advice at Atlanta's stores is not all equally good, but there are two stores which will probably continue to get most of our business. It's worth comparing prices for dry goods; even among our sponsors prices can vary widely.

Like any hobby, from working on old cars to playing the piano, you get out of it what you put into it. If books bore you, find a mentor. It doesn't have to be someone from an LFS--find someone who has built a tank you like and ask them how they did it. Ask them what they would do differently. We all love to talk about our tanks!
 
I'd go one further along one of the points Organ Builder (awesome profession, BTW) raises. As a nano/pico owner there's lots of things for sale online that just don't show up in our local stores that I'd LIKE to get... but I genuinely won't because it is so very important to see the critter first.

A pity but I just don't see how to do it any other way than local for my own preferred approach. Liveaquaria's great as a quick spot research but I really, really value being able to assess the fish/crab/shrimp/coral/whatever's general health & appearance BEFORE it's in my tank. Going Diver's Den/WYSIWYG plus the typical $40-60 shipping to have a chance of it getting to you alive eats whatever "savings" you might get online. And to be fair, several sponsor stores have started carrying nano-friendly livestock in enough variety to make it interesting to shop.

I think I commented in this thread a couple years ago when I was younger in the hobby. Although we've lost some great local stores (Imagine Ocean & recently SEA's showroom location come to mind) I still regard local as the mainstay of my foray into this hobby. It's just more fun to look & spot something you'd fine neat than it is to browse online for it, IMO.
 
i support LFS when i can. i prefer them to online.

however, sometimes their stock lacks. or they sell to the masses. (yay zoas).
when i want a specific item and their inventory doesnt change, i will go online.

here is my biggest gripe to every LFS ive visited in the metro atlanta area.

where the hell are your millis? i can name one store that has a few millis and i go by his place when i can.
if i cant even get a basic coral genus from most lfs... why should i support them?

my .02
 
Stores have to sell what people buy consistently.

I carried mostly 'bread and butter' stuff because that what kept the bills paid.

When I'd get something rare (read: expensive), it would often live there for a while, to the delight of all the whistling gophers.

What's a whistling gopher?

"That's pretty - what's it gopher?" (go for).

Me: "That's $XXX" (Insert price that is higher than $9.99)

"**Whistles**" and shakes head.

The market for the higher dollar stuff is much narrower than the market for the stuff that 'everyone' can afford.

Why should you support them? Because the day your return pump takes a dump and you don't have a spare one, you cannot wait 3 days for the etailer to ship you a new one. Most locals will go above and beyond too, even if it means staying late, coming in early or otherwise accommodating an after-hours disaster, loaning equipment/resources...

Posts like the one above make me glad I packed it in :) You can never please everyone.

Communicating with your local about the kinds of things you are looking for can help too. Keep in mind that not everything is available all the time either.

When Purple Tangs were 'out of season', everybody wanted one. When they were in season, nobody wanted one. Sometimes the storekeeper can't win for losing.

Jenn
 
I buy food, fish, and some coral from various LFS (spread out between 4 shops) but buy all of my equipment, most of my coral, and some dry food online.
 
JennM;1065433 wrote: Stores have to sell what people buy consistently.

I carried mostly 'bread and butter' stuff because that what kept the bills paid.

When I'd get something rare (read: expensive), it would often live there for a while, to the delight of all the whistling gophers.

What's a whistling gopher?

"That's pretty - what's it gopher?" (go for).

Me: "That's $XXX" (Insert price that is higher than $9.99)

"**Whistles**" and shakes head.

The market for the higher dollar stuff is much narrower than the market for the stuff that 'everyone' can afford.

Why should you support them? Because the day your return pump takes a dump and you don't have a spare one, you cannot wait 3 days for the etailer to ship you a new one. Most locals will go above and beyond too, even if it means staying late, coming in early or otherwise accommodating an after-hours disaster, loaning equipment/resources...

Posts like the one above make me glad I packed it in :) You can never please everyone.

Communicating with your local about the kinds of things you are looking for can help too. Keep in mind that not everything is available all the time either.

When Purple Tangs were 'out of season', everybody wanted one. When they were in season, nobody wanted one. Sometimes the storekeeper can't win for losing.

Jenn

milliapora is a very basic genus of coral.
think what you will, but blaming customers on your lack of business is telling

customer is always right in every business. i would not as a business owner think i know whats best for the customer more than they
 
Wow, you're rude.

There's no such thing as a 'Milliapora" as you put it.

Are you referring to Acropora millepora? Or perhaps Millepora</em> alcicornis, which is also known as Fire Coral - which is illegal to collect?

You know nothing about me, nor of my business.

Jenn
 
Russ-IV;1065430 wrote:
here is my biggest gripe to every LFS ive visited in the metro atlanta area.

where the hell are your millis? i can name one store that has a few millis and i go by his place when i can.
if i cant even get a basic coral genus from most lfs... why should i support them?

my .02

I have kept a lot of Millis and found most LFS's do not stock a lot but, a coupe of my best millis came from Atlanta Aquarium and The Fish Store. While my taste in corals trends toward the higher end that most LFS's don't regularly stock, some owners are more than happy to keep and eye open or track stuff down. Rit over at Atlanta Aquarium has done this for me.

I have also had a lot of success with finding some great Millis form other club members (Reeferman to name one).
 
Back
Top