More than 2 clownfish

lsu_fishfan

Active Member
Market
Messages
1,157
Reaction score
0
How many people have successfully kept more than one pair of clowns in their tank? I remember reading about people keeping trios, and sometimes multiple pairs. So what is your opinions/experience with this? If there is more than one pair, will the females fight to the death? Or if you add them young, will only one clown be dominant with multiple males? Thanks
 
I was at a customer site today. A woman there had a 66 gallon with 4 clowns. Two different varieties of clowns.

They pretty much split the tank. Each pair had it's own turf and seldom crosses into the other's area.
 
I've had a trio of ocellaris in my 75gal for a long time now, with absolutely no issues. Judging by size I've two females and one little male, and they all share two large RBTAs.

<img src="
2014-08-20211757.jpg
alt="" /></a>" alt="" /&gt;
 
Stickman;1034290 wrote: Check out marine depot clown fish herium tank on YouTube.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=CQsFg4PWViM">https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=CQsFg4PWViM</a>[/QUOTE]


Bulk Reef Supply not Marine Depot just FYI
 
EDIT : JB, you have a male, a female and a sub adult.

My findings from over the years(while working at a LFS) and my personal experiences.

People with larger tanks(5' or more) can usually get away with 2 pairs(of the same or different species) if the anemones stay at opposite ends of the tank. But an anemone is a must in order to keep the pairs in their respective territories. But dont try it with maroons, they are downright evil.

If you want more than a pair of a single species, it gets tricky. The only way I have ever seen it work is when the group is purchased at the same time when they are all sub adult (not male or female yet) and this usually only works in large groups of 8 or more.

Successes I have seen were a tank with almost 30 perculas, a tank with a group of 5 ocellaris, a tank with a pair of percs and clarks and a tank with a pair of percs and ocellaris.

I ended up trying it with 5 three month old, tank bread onyx clowns from JJ about 5 years ago.

All went well for the first 8-10 months or so. The larger one became female and the second largest one became male. Then two more turned male, and the fights started. The two smaller males would fight(not damaging each other but chasing) non stop, and I mean non stop for a week before I decided one had to be removed. They fought so much they didnt even notice the net coming for them.

Peace lasted about a week before the remaining two males started going at it. Same result, removed the other male.

I now have 3 onyx clowns. A pair and a sub adult that they will not allow anywhere near the anemone. He hangs out in my flowerpot. The pair never does anything harmful toward him, but they dont like him. Hes like the annoying friend no one wants around. They all got along decently when there was no anemone in the system though.

They have been living just fine like that ever since.

EDIT 2 found a pic of the clowns when I got them
34851_1446307471623_3858647_n.jpg
 
EnderG60;1034338 wrote: EDIT : JB, you have a male, a female and a sub adult.

My findings from over the years(while working at a LFS) and my personal experiences.

People with larger tanks(5' or more) can usually get away with 2 pairs(of the same or different species) if the anemones stay at opposite ends of the tank. But an anemone is a must in order to keep the pairs in their respective territories. But dont try it with maroons, they are downright evil.

If you want more than a pair of a single species, it gets tricky. The only way I have ever seen it work is when the group is purchased at the same time when they are all sub adult (not male or female yet) and this usually only works in large groups of 8 or more.

Successes I have seen were a tank with almost 30 perculas, a tank with a group of 5 ocellaris, a tank with a pair of percs and clarks and a tank with a pair of percs and ocellaris.

I ended up trying it with 5 three month old, tank bread onyx clowns from JJ about 5 years ago.

All went well for the first 8-10 months or so. The larger one became female and the second largest one became male. Then two more turned male, and the fights started. The two smaller males would fight(not damaging each other but chasing) non stop, and I mean non stop for a week before I decided one had to be removed. They fought so much they didnt even notice the net coming for them.

Peace lasted about a week before the remaining two males started going at it. Same result, removed the other male.

I now have 3 onyx clowns. A pair and a sub adult that they will not allow anywhere near the anemone. He hangs out in my flowerpot. The pair never does anything harmful toward him, but they dont like him. Hes like the annoying friend no one wants around. They all got along decently when there was no anemone in the system though.

They have been living just fine like that ever since.

EDIT 2 found a pic of the clowns when I got them
https://scontent.xx.fbcdn.net/hphotos-xat1/v/t1.0-9/s552x414/34851_1446307471623_3858647_n.jpg?oh=c1ac2e51d386ec5888b88442139a9423&oe=5608C2AC" alt="" />[/QUOTE]

Thanks for all the info. I have a 250 gallon dd so 5' by 3' and I just added a pair of juvinial Picasso clowns this past weekend. Currently there are no nems in the tank. From what you have said, I think it's best to stick with one pair for the fishes health.
 
I started with 4 OC clowns. they beat one near death after being together for 9 months and i rescued, then had 3. one pair and one solo, the pair was laying eggs for about 4 months then the solo guy brought the smake down on the daddy. Mommy defended for a little but then gave up and once husband #1 was beat down pretty bad, she joined with the solo guy and started trying to kill her ex-husband. Rescued the poor fella and mommy and husband #2 been laying eggs atleast 5 months and are the only 2 clowns in the tank. 110 gallon tank fwiw.
 
I concur with what EnderG60 said.

I've seen limited success in larger tanks but it also depends on the attitude of the fishes themselves.

I had a customer with a 220 gallon tank and a mean nasty pair of Tomato clowns that were probably 10 years old.

Unknown to me, a Petco opened up nearby and the guy went and bought 8 little ocellaris clowns. The meanies killed every one. I only knew about them because when I went to clean the tank, the guy's wife asked me if I found any of them. I cleaned the tank every other week, so at some point between cleanings, all 8 fish were added, and all 8 were killed off. I'd have never known if the wife hadn't spilled the beans. ;)

The bigger question other than is it 'doable', is whether or not it's advisable or recommended. Nearly anything is 'doable' but whether or not it will make for a peaceful environment is the bigger question. Clowns duking it out for territory can stress everything in the tank.

Just food for thought.

Jenn
 
Back
Top