rdnelson99;899270 wrote: You make very good points. However, I believe you make a conclusion that may not always be fact. If all of your statements are 100% accurate, how would you explain that my tank has had absolutely no sign of ich in over 6 months? I did not leave the tank fallow and I did not medicate the fish with either of the meds you suggest. You method is a good one but not the only one. I believe heathy fish can fight off the parasite to the point where even the eggs do not survive. But of course, I could be wrong.
I am going on a cruise.....on my lawnmower around my yard.
What's Up Rich?!?!??! Howz it going?
From what I've researched and experienced, a fish can be a carrier of ich for quite a while without showing it. Same with flukes, internal parasites, etc... Also fish aren't the only way ich can get into your system. Not proven, but possible that adding inverts, corals, LR, etc from infected tanks can introduce it to your system (From what I've read, not experience). Honestly, 100% eradication requires so much work that the hobby will become un-enjoyable. We can only do our best at minimizing the risk. I'll be the first to admit that what I say isn't 100% fact. Nothing in this hobby is, but I've learned allot through my pains. LOL...
I also went on a cruise. To the Mexican Restaraunt around the corner on my golf cart. :thumbs:
Edit:
rdnelson99;899280 wrote: At the right strength, with a long enough exposure yes. But, not all water flows through the UV at any given time and only the parasites that are suspended in that water will be killed. Those in the sand and rocks are unaffected. But, it is way to reduce the numbers substantially.
I am going on a cruise.....on my lawnmower around my yard.
+1
Edit:
phnman372;899290 wrote: CedzAquAddiction
"This keeps the fish's appetite strong (thereby keeping the fish strong), and helps keeping them eating through the infestation. One of the first signs of infestation are the fish stop eating."
That is just it. He is eating like crazy now and before. Heck he has even put weight on since I have had him. His belly was sunken in a little. Now it is filled out and he is nice and thick. If it wasn't for the spots you wouldn't think he had anything. That is the strongest reason that I am not taking them out. Yes it may kill all of them, which is not what I (or anyone else) wants to happen. But then again it may kill him by moving him again which is what I believe started this in the first place. Please don't think that I think you are wrong or I do not want to listen, that couldn't be more wrong. I want the best for them. I am still very new to the saltwater world. I have always had some type of freshwater tank for many many years. I read and ask question on things. I talk to people both on this forum and off to try to find the best answer I can come up with. Worry about it day and night.Nobody wants to get it wrong. Even the best approaches fail. So here is to not failing and trying.
No problems, Man. None of this is personal. I've been schooled by many more experienced reefers on this site, and continue to do so every day. Just giving my advice from my reading and experience. QT is an absolute PITA, but I do it regardless. I'll admit that I've lost MANY fish in QT, but have comfort that those that make it through QT have a lesser chance of infecting my DT or the fish in it...
Quick question... Are you absolutely sure it's ich? Any pictures you can share? We are all here to help. Hope I didn't come off as being rude, or arrogant. That was definetely not my intent. Being new to this hobby is intimidating enough without brown eyes taking shots at you. LOL...
Pardon my spelling or grammar. I'm vodka dosing (myself) at the time. :Banane35:
Edit:
rdnelson99;899296 wrote: Don't worry too much about what we think. 99% of us understand there are many ways and others may not think ours is the best way. The key is to get lots of opinions, weigh them all and then make an informed decision. Do that and you will have a great tank with happy livestock.
I am going on a cruise.....on my lawnmower around my yard.
Best advice given yet. Not all tanks are the same, so not all remedies will apply to every tank. :thumbs:
