- Messages
- 1,126
- Reaction score
- 0
It definitely can, but just about everything he sells are under 250w radiums. He likes his radions but has admitted not getting the same amount of growth from them.
Not real happy with reef breeders led and sps...add T5 for better growth? Or go MH?
- Thread starter davidinga
- Start date
It definitely can, but just about everything he sells are under 250w radiums. He likes his radions but has admitted not getting the same amount of growth from them.
- Messages
- 1,126
- Reaction score
- 0
Were you running a chiller? Usually that's going to be the source of heat. I know my office gets pretty warm in the summer with the DT in there.
- Messages
- 886
- Reaction score
- 0
No chiller just two fans in the canopy
- Messages
- 886
- Reaction score
- 0
Yes and you don't do such a bad job yourself running an led lit tank. Very nice stuff
not so true.i speak with Adam just about every week and he tells me all the time how much he loves leds.a lot of the stuff he sells is grown under led,just ask him,hes very forthright with his setup.
thanks Mike,ive never had a problem growing or coloring any acros under my leds and have been doing it for well over 3 years
No expert but it seems from an outside perspective that MH gives you a little more room for error, but LED is less forgiving. It seems that if you have everything else in check then LED works great but MH will still grow corals even if the water chemistry is not perfect
exactly right...but,if water chemistry is not perfect,youre not gonna be able to get the most out of acros regardless of what light you are implementing
- Messages
- 886
- Reaction score
- 0
Yea you don't know it but you were the nail in the coffin for my MH. I had been thinking about it for awhile and took the plung. Could not be happier with growth of color ( well except for my joes rainbow). Very much alive just in neutral.
- Messages
- 1,126
- Reaction score
- 0
We text and talk regularly being from the same part of the country and me generally being annoying (and grabbing a few packs). Says he loves his radions but growth is a bit slower, also runs them with vhos in a prop tank and likes the color there. Has them in his DT because he's not going for just all out growth and made a comment about moving his blue panther back to the radiums as it's lost a bit of color when I told him I moved mine to the radium tank and it turned more blue. We've never talked about reef breeders, but I don't doubt he likes those too. I know he had/has a lot of LPS for awhile and that those were mainly under LED. Not sure which ones.
I'm definitely not trying to argue about which is better or disparage LEDs in any way. I have a radion and like it a lot. Just pointing out that I didn't think they were the key to his "acro success" based on our conversations.
- Messages
- 1,126
- Reaction score
- 0
my understanding is that you're a heck of a reefer and so is adam... you could both make it work any way, but idiots like me need training wheels.
josh, i think hit the nail on the head with his margin of error comment.
seth the wine guy
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 1,356
- Reaction score
- 30
I haven't had time to post the breakdown of Sanjay Joshi's presentation at MACNA this month on switching his 500g tank from MH to Radions this year.
My feelings on LED and MH are pretty widely known amongst those who've been around here a while. But, I will say that Sanjay had nothing to report that would make me want to take my halides off the tank anytime soon.
Bottom line, he had to end up running the same total watts of LED as he did halide to achieve the same coverage and PAR values. He admitted the only reason he did it was the fact that his chiller failed while he was at MACNA the previous year and wiped out his tank. He said he just never wanted to worry about a chiller again. His break even period factoring in ALL variables was 3.5 years with the Radions. (And that's paying a discounted $600 per fixture.) He also estimated about 80% growth with LED compared to MH. He also said he had several acros that simply won't grow at all that used to grow like a weed for him under MH.
BUT, all that aside, I still stand by my original post in this thread that I think the OP should confirm other parameters prior to switching because it CAN be done with the fixtures he has now. Just more difficult to.
My feelings on LED and MH are pretty widely known amongst those who've been around here a while. But, I will say that Sanjay had nothing to report that would make me want to take my halides off the tank anytime soon.
Bottom line, he had to end up running the same total watts of LED as he did halide to achieve the same coverage and PAR values. He admitted the only reason he did it was the fact that his chiller failed while he was at MACNA the previous year and wiped out his tank. He said he just never wanted to worry about a chiller again. His break even period factoring in ALL variables was 3.5 years with the Radions. (And that's paying a discounted $600 per fixture.) He also estimated about 80% growth with LED compared to MH. He also said he had several acros that simply won't grow at all that used to grow like a weed for him under MH.
BUT, all that aside, I still stand by my original post in this thread that I think the OP should confirm other parameters prior to switching because it CAN be done with the fixtures he has now. Just more difficult to.
i would agree that the other params need to be checked and confirmed and be very stable.
im not arguing growth either,mh are king for growth but really,im not interested near as much with growth as i am with color.my acros grow very well but as Seth said,maybe 80% comparative.
i certainly dont believe the leds are the key to Adams success either,i was just pointing out that it could be done and if he was comfortable with them,they must do alright.
im not arguing growth either,mh are king for growth but really,im not interested near as much with growth as i am with color.my acros grow very well but as Seth said,maybe 80% comparative.
i certainly dont believe the leds are the key to Adams success either,i was just pointing out that it could be done and if he was comfortable with them,they must do alright.
Wow that's nuts that it took an equal amount of LED watts to what he had in MH before! All things being equal most of us running LED's are probably waaaaay under lit!
I can also attest to the statement that some acro's simply refuse to grow under my LED's. They just sit there with that funny look on their faces as if to say "that's not real light, I'm not growing".
Well I'm going MH now 
Gonna stick the leds in the closet for now.
alt="" />
Picked up a used set of 250w gear for $190. It came with:
2x lumen bright minis
1x lumen max
3x radium bulbs (4 months old)
2x coralvue ballasts
1x galaxy ballast
I'm debating adding some T5's now for tank viewing when the mh lights are off.
Gonna stick the leds in the closet for now.
Picked up a used set of 250w gear for $190. It came with:
2x lumen bright minis
1x lumen max
3x radium bulbs (4 months old)
2x coralvue ballasts
1x galaxy ballast
I'm debating adding some T5's now for tank viewing when the mh lights are off.
- Messages
- 1,126
- Reaction score
- 0
DavidinGA;987365 wrote: Well I'm going MH now
Gonna stick the leds in the closet for now.
alt="" />
Picked up a used set of 250w gear for $190. It came with:
2x lumen bright minis
1x lumen max
3x radium bulbs (4 months old)
2x coralvue ballasts
1x galaxy ballast
I'm debating adding some T5's now for tank viewing when the mh lights are off.
Congrats, that's a pretty sick deal! You'll love it.
- Messages
- 886
- Reaction score
- 0
Don't say I didn't warn you next summer hehehehe. Congrats that was a good deal
Similar threads
